Wednesday, 28 November 2007
| Overall rating (weighted) |
|
4.5 |
| Musicianship |
|
4.0 |
| Composition |
|
4.0 |
| Experimentation |
|
3.0 |
| Production |
|
8.0 |
| Value |
|
5.0 |
When a band changes their sound, there are many reasons to consider. Is it personal, physical, political, or aesthetic reasons? Do they take into consideration their fan base when accounting for the change? Are they doing it for the art in the end?
The End, a Canadian metal band that has been around for some time, has released two albums of astonishing musical accomplishment. Their first release, 'Transfer Trachea...,' was a quite unique and fascinating glimpse into what a band with completely new ideas of composition and tone can do in the small 'tech metal' genre. The band achieved good underground success but didn't break into the public eye until the release of their second album on Relapse Records called 'Within Dividia.'
Different in outward complexity, 'Within Dividia' is complicated in another way: atmosphere. Normally, music relying solely on atmosphere and not as much on composition has bothered me. 'Within Dividia' has crossed the threshold as to what 'tech metal' meant. The album is a musically complete masterpiece of technicality and mood, a record that was as subtle as it was bombastic.
Flash forward a couple years. The End has another album coming. One would assume that the musical ideas, such as the band's personalized sense of organic disharmony, would be in full blast here. The first few seconds of 'Elementary' reveal something different. Not nearly as apocalyptic-sounding as 'Within Dividia,' as well as sporting a much cleaner mix, "Dangerous" is a step towards new sound and new musical intent. For starters, there are fewer changes in the playing of all the instruments. The songs are less heavy and devastating, more straightforward even, and there is even another previously-unseen element: clean singing.
Given The End's musical track record, this is an anomaly. Perhaps the following tracks would give way to more of the signature The End style. No such luck. "The Never Aftermath" is the perfect example of the new sound: traditional alterna/metal-sounding songs with verse-bridge-chorus structure bolstered by some occasional metal screaming and heaviness. Much of this album could be played on mainstream heavy rock radio with lots of fanfare and attention. Thematically and musically, 'Elementary' is a complete album. Not nearly has black-sounding as their previous efforts, this new release is softer, more delicate and certainly streamlined; not angry, threatening and original-sounding.
The End is utilizing a style that has been around for quite some time: clean vocals with metal riffs. The jumping from clean to scream is not an original idea. The style is quite popular with many people who appreciate a straightforward listen. Given that this style is coming from The End, who made their impact with two highly regarded albums in a fringe-but-burgeoning genre of extreme music, one can only wonder their reasoning.
This will be both alarming to previous fans as well as new listeners. There is no doubt that this album will solidify the band's future. This album will lose fewer fans than it will gain new ones. The End's sense of composure is still present, but the uniqueness that set them apart from the other bands that flood stores like FYE, Best Buy and even Myspace is nil.
There is one thing The End does with 'Elementary:' make the music they want to make. In the intention of continuing to create the music they care so much about, The End has succeeded. In regards to the fans that helped make them recognized in the first place, many will feel left out and abandoned. There is very little that connects the very aspect that made them who they are in the first place with the new entity they have now become.
Last updated: Wednesday, 28 November 2007