Tuesday, 27 November 2007
| Overall rating (weighted) |
|
4.7 |
| Musicianship |
|
5.0 |
| Composition |
|
5.0 |
| Experimentation |
|
2.0 |
| Production |
|
8.0 |
| Value |
|
5.0 |
First thing I noticed about this band is their utmost unique and original name. Out of 350 bands with 3 words that start with as, all, dies, beneath and blood... All Shall Perish certain stands out above them. If you can't put time and effort into your band name, what makes me think you'd do that same with your music? Hey guess what? They didn't put any time effort in their music...the name fits. By the second song they are play so many nu metal riffs you'd think its 1998 again. By the way, you forgot to turn your metronome off. Before you start reminiscing, sevendust begins to play a breakdown (again). By this time the hyped guitar playing starts to doodle over these breakdowns. That way when I attempt to watch them play I can blindly be slammed in the back of the head by the most unmannered Hardcore dancers.
I won't deny their drummer's ability to switch drum beats at incredible speeds. His ride work and accents are very good but he's not saving the rest of the band. The generic chord progression in the 5th track was extremely refreshing. I was re-assuremed that the rest of the album is going nowhere and I should have stopped at their fucking name. The gang vocals are the icing on the cake. They sound so disgustingly cut and place. His bree singing is way over used and sounds clashingly. Such a raspy technique over such clean music does seem to work well. I think its better left for goregrind bands and IVEBEENSHOT. The best song on the album is Prisoner of War. I enjoyed its high use of layering and in dabble in epic black metal but by the time the solo starts I'm already bored again. The interlude on the album is your classic metalcore instrumental. While certainly giving Shadow's Fall's "Casting Shade" and Killswitch Engage's "Without a Name" a run for their money it still doesn't get very far.
Just to show you how much I'm willing to listen to this album to show how shitty it is, check the stats.
1. Eradication (1st breakdown 45secs, 2nd breakdown 26 secs, 3rd breakdown 40 secs)
2. Wage Slaves (1st breakdown 30 secs, 2nd breakdown 37 secs, 3rd breakdown 46 secs, 4th breakdown 55 secs)
3. The Day Of Justice (1st breakdown 40 secs, 2nd breakdown 40 secs)
4. There Is No Business To Be Done On A Dead Planet (1st breakdown 20 secs, 2nd breakdown 60 secs, 3rd breakdown 17 secs)
5. Better Living Through Catastrophe (1st breakdown 17 secs, 2nd breakdown 37 secs, 3rd breakdown 25 secs)
6. Prisoner Of War (1st breakdown 15 secs, 2nd breakdown 60 secs) 7. Interlude (none)
8. We Hold These Truths... (1st breakdown 50 secs, 2nd breakdown 40 secs, 3rd breakdown 12 secs)
9. The True Beast (1st breakdown 35 secs, 2nd breakdown 36 secs, 3rd breakdown 66 secs)
10. Promises (1st breakdown 182 secs (the whole fucking song))
11. The Last Relapse (1st breakdown 25 secs, 2nd breakdown 45 secs)
1161 seconds of breakdowns/19.35 minutes of breakdowns in an album that's only 42.3 minutes long. Need I say more? Even if I wasn't dogging breakdowns, the other 22.95 minutes of music isn't that good either. Granted this is a band centered on breakdowns but if they consume half of your album, make them more creative. I'm glad to see Deathcore and Metalcore becoming better at their instruments yet big timers like All Shall Perish are still lagging in unique song writing and forward thinking music. To dumb it down for you; bass drops, brees and breakdowns are played out already and this couldn't be a better example. Obviously All Shall Perish fully embraces the trend, now they need to take it further and change it.
Last updated: Friday, 14 December 2007